|
Publications and Press Releases :
Press Release
: News Archives
Budget Speech by the Financial Secretary
*************************************************
Following is the full text of the Speech on the 2004-05
Budget delivered by the Financial Secretary, Mr Henry Tang, in the
Legislative Council today (March 10):
Madam President,
Introduction
I move that the Appropriation Bill 2004 be read a second time.
2. 2003 was a challenging year for Hong Kong. We came through a
difficult period following the outbreak of SARS. Later, things took
a turn for the better as our economy staged a rapid rebound. That
we have been able to turn market sentiment around within the space
of a few short months demonstrates the tenacity of Hong Kong people.
In the face of adversity, we remain remarkably tough and resilient.
When confronted with unexpected misfortune, we display determination
and solidarity, and rise to the challenge through our quick wits,
adaptability to change, and our ability to seize the moment.
3. The past year clearly demonstrated the great advantage we have
in leveraging on our special relationship with the Mainland while
engaging the world at large. Immediately after overcoming the outbreak
of SARS, we signed the Mainland/Hong Kong Closer Economic Partnership
Arrangement (CEPA), bringing unprecedented opportunities to all
sectors of our economy. Our manufacturing and services industries
have been given early access to the greatest potential market in
the world, thus providing a further catalyst to our economic restructuring.
The launch of the Individual Visit Scheme and the Renminbi (RMB)
business initiative have further enhanced the free flow of people,
goods and capital in both directions, speeding up our economic integration.
This has fostered our economy's rapid recovery and laid a strong
foundation for sustainable development.
4. Our motherland is currently the fastest-growing major economy
in the world. Despite the effects of SARS, her economy registered
strong growth of 9.1 per cent last year; her Gross Domestic Product
(GDP) exceeded US$1,400 billion, breaking through the US$1,000 mark
on a per capita basis and hitting a historical high. As China transforms
herself into a nation in which everyone may enjoy a reasonable standard
of living, her economy should continue to grow steadily apace, and,
looking forward, her GDP is expected to reach US$4,000 billion by
2020. Hong Kong can complement the strong economic growth of our
motherland, and in the process contribute to the further opening-up
and reform of our nation.
5. We must, however, always bear it in mind that Hong Kong is a
cosmopolitan international city. We have an abundant pool of talent,
enterprise, experience and facilities that connect us to the rest
of the world. We should be alive to opportunities on the Mainland,
but at the same time, we should not lose sight of what the world
at large has to offer. Only with such breadth of mind and vision
can we maintain our position as the best business platform for China
and the rest of the world.
6. These advantages flow from the principle of "One Country,
Two Systems". Some may say that CEPA is a big present from
the Central People's Government (CPG) to Hong Kong, but as Premier
Wen Jiabao remarked on his visit to Hong Kong last year, the greatest
gift is actually the CPG's unwavering commitment to implement "One
Country, Two Systems". If we can fully capitalise on our unique
advantage under "One Country, Two Systems" and enhance
our competitiveness in the globalised economy, this will hold the
key to a brighter future for our people.
Directions for Development
Market Leads, Government Facilitates
7. A free market economy is the bedrock of Hong Kong's success.
I firmly believe that our guiding principle in fostering economic
development should be "market leads and government facilitates".
Having come from the business sector, I am keenly aware that the
essential ingredients for the success of an enterprise are flexibility,
a quick response and the ability to see where the market is heading.
The Government's principal role is to create the best possible environment
for business and to facilitate the market's operation and promote
its development. This role includes -
* Maintaining a robust institutional framework, underpinned by individual
freedoms, the rule of law, a clean and highly efficient government,
a safe and stable society and a good working and living environment.
* Providing a business-friendly environment, by maintaining free
trade and the free flow of information, promoting fair competition,
enhancing the quality of the market and upgrading human resources.
* Maintaining a healthy fiscal and monetary regime, with prudent
management of public finances, maintenance of a freely-convertible
and stable currency and a sound regulatory system.
* Safeguarding and promoting Hong Kong's commercial and trade interests,
namely, securing more favourable market access for our enterprises
through bilateral and multilateral economic and trade negotiations.
* Providing the essential services and facilities that the market
cannot provide, including major networks of infrastructure and provision
of basic necessities for the disadvantaged to live with dignity.
8. We will continue to give free rein to market forces. We will
ensure clarity, predictability and consistency in our policies to
enable investors to make informed business decisions for the long
term.
Revitalising the Economy, Promoting Employment
9. I have stressed many times since taking this post that my foremost
priority is to revitalise Hong Kong's economy. Thanks to the concerted
efforts of the whole community, market sentiment has been improving
significantly in the past few months. Although our economy is picking
up, employment remains a serious challenge for us. As a long-term
solution, we should promote Hong Kong's economic restructuring,
become more competitive, and broaden and deepen our markets. With
further improvement in our economy and increase in investment, more
employment opportunities will follow.
10. Some labour organisations have told me they are worried that
the local employment situation might not improve despite an economic
recovery. Actually, this phenomenon is not unique to Hong Kong.
As globalisation intensifies competition, manufacturing industries
and even some service industries will move to other competitive
locations that have lower costs, giving rise to job losses. In his
Policy Address in January, the Chief Executive announced some targeted
short-term measures to ease the problem of unemployment. I have
obtained the approval of the Finance Committee to grant about $1.2
billion to extend more than 11 000 temporary jobs, to provide young
people with opportunities to gain work experience and enhance skills
through training and to assist them to become self-employed. I have
also earmarked $50 million to establish a Youth Sustainable Development
and Engagement Fund. Our determination to introduce these employment
initiatives in the face of the fiscal deficit shows the importance
that we attach to employment by targetting the necessary expenditure
measures. In addition, the Government will improve its employment
and training services and crack down on the employment of illegal
workers so as to safeguard jobs for the local workforce.
11. Economic revitalisation and promotion of employment are crucial
for Hong Kong's development and are inextricably intertwined. The
newly-established Economic and Employment Council has drawn its
members from various sectors, providing a forum for representatives
from the political sphere, trade and labour organisations and academia
to discuss important economic and employment issues, to share collective
wisdom and through co-ordination and prioritisation build up a consensus
in different policy areas. This new initiative will help the Government
to work more closely with various sectors of the community to promote
economic activities, encourage investment, facilitate business and
create more employment opportunities.
Capitalising on the Mainland/Hong Kong Closer Economic
Partnership Arrangement
12. The signing of CEPA is the best embodiment of
the "market leads and government facilitates" principle.
It is also a prime example of how "One Country, Two Systems"
benefits Hong Kong. In the Mainland, the demand for quality goods
and services from enterprises and individuals alike has surged following
years of rapid economic growth. At this crucial juncture, CEPA has
ushered in a new phase of comprehensive economic co-operation between
Hong Kong and the Mainland. Apart from generating unlimited "win-win"
opportunities, CEPA also gives overseas multinational enterprises
the chance to use Hong Kong to access the Mainland market. Our position
as a two-way platform for business and trade will be greatly enhanced.
This will inject new impetus into our economy and, at the same time,
facilitate our economic restructuring and increase employment opportunities.
13. Currently, 374 Hong Kong-made products can be
exported to the Mainland tariff-free. Other Hong Kong products will
also enjoy zero-tariff treatment by 1 January 2006 at the latest.
In the short span of two months since CEPA came into operation,
over 300 CEPA certificates of origin have been issued, with the
value of products enjoying preferential treatment at around $150
million.
14. The zero-tariff treatment gives Hong Kong products
the edge over overseas products in penetration of the Mainland market.
This will provide an added incentive for the manufacturers of brand
name products and products with high added-value and significant
intellectual property content to locate their production lines in
Hong Kong. This will encourage the structural adjustment of our
industries towards further diversification and high-value-added
and high-tech production.
15. CEPA provides 18 major service sectors, including
the professions, banking and finance, retail and distribution, communications
and audio-visual and logistics, with market access that is far more
favourable than under China's commitments to the WTO. This enables
professionals and companies in Hong Kong to enjoy the advantage
of preferential access to the vast Mainland market. It also helps
Hong Kong attract inward investment, thus further reinforcing the
status of Hong Kong as a major business and service centre in the
Asia-Pacific region. In addition, Hong Kong permanent residents
of Chinese nationality may operate individually-owned retail businesses
in Guangdong.
16. The conference on professional services held in
Beijing last month made good progress in many areas, including mutual
recognition of professional qualifications and practising requirements.
We will continue to hold discussions with the Mainland authorities
on the mutual recognition of professional qualifications and the
entry threshold for different sectors in order to enable Hong Kong's
service providers to play fully to their strengths in the Mainland
market.
17. The Government attaches much importance to the
successful implementation of CEPA and will spare no effort to provide
the necessary support for this. We may encounter some difficulties
in the initial phase of implementation. We invite the business sector
to report to us immediately any bottlenecks or administrative obstacles
encountered in any particular area. The Mainland and Hong Kong authorities
will take swift action to tackle them. We will continue to discuss
with the sectors concerned how to formulate policies and measures
to enable businesses in Hong Kong to reap the maximum benefit from
CEPA.
18. CEPA is an ever-developing platform. We will continue
our efforts to reinforce and expand it in order to provide more
favourable market access conditions for our businesses. The CEPA
platform has unlimited horizons. But blazing a successful trail
will require the various sectors to take their opportunities and
make the most of them.
19. We envisage that CEPA will speed up our economic
co-operation with the Mainland, particularly with the Pearl River
Delta (PRD). The 15 expert groups established under the Hong Kong/Guangdong
Co-operation Joint Conference have started work in their different
areas. In order to enhance the competitiveness of the Greater PRD,
we will strive to improve the economic infrastructure of the region.
The Shenzhen Western Corridor and the new cross-boundary vehicular
bridge at the Lok Ma Chau/Huanggang Control Point, both of which
are already under construction, will further facilitate the flow
of people and goods between Hong Kong and Guangdong. The Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macao
Bridge, which is now under planning, will draw us closer to our
hinterland. Better access to western Guangdong will also help us
tap the new business opportunities over there. The economic co-operation
between Hong Kong and Guangdong represents the alliance of a strong
manufacturing base with a centre of international finance, trade,
shipping, logistics and high value-added services. The strengths
of the Greater PRD region are all-embracing and unique. With its
world-class potential, Hong Kong can play a key role as a business
platform. Our primary task is to seize the opportunities for development
that CEPA brings.
20. Such opportunities are not confined to Guangdong
alone. We convened the first meeting of the Hong Kong/Shanghai Economic
and Trade Co-operation Conference in October last year with a view
to reinforcing our economic ties with Shanghai and creating business
opportunities together within the framework of CEPA. There is already
a strong friendship between the people of Hong Kong and Shanghai.
I believe that, as we complement each other's strengths, the co-operation
and understanding between our two cities will definitely be enhanced.
We will also continue to increase our economic and trade co-operation
with other provinces and cities for our mutual benefit.
Investing in Education and Training, Attracting Talent
21. The competitiveness of an economy depends largely
on the quality and productivity of its human resources. For Hong
Kong, these are our single most precious asset. To enable our economy
to meet the challenges of the 21st Century, we must effectively
nurture and attract talent. As Hong Kong develops into a knowledge-based
economy, we will need more talented individuals who are biliterate
and trilingual, who possess a broad vision and have the ability
to communicate effectively, think critically and be innovative and
adaptable. Through training and retraining of our workforce, we
will help them to help themselves by enhancing their knowledge and
skills.
22. Despite our huge fiscal deficit, we will continue
to devote enormous resources to education. Expenditure on education
in 2004-05 will amount to $59.5 billion and account for 23 per cent
of government expenditure. This represents a significant increase
of 57 per cent from $37.9 billion in 1996-97. We will continue to
invest in education and strive to enhance its quality.
23. All over the world there is competition for talent
to meet the challenges of globalisation. In the past, Hong Kong
imposed many restrictions on admission of Mainland professionals,
and this has not helped our development. With the increasingly deep
economic integration between Hong Kong and the Mainland, we need
more talented people from there. Such people possess expertise and
experience as well as better understanding of the Mainland market
and its culture. They will provide valuable assistance in opening
up Mainland opportunities. With further training and exposure to
international practices, they will become valuable assets for our
enterprises and the Hong Kong-based overseas companies eyeing the
Mainland market.
24. In mid-July last year, the Government introduced
the Admission Scheme for Mainland Talents and Professionals, essentially
aligning the criteria with those for admitting talented people from
other places. This scheme provides Hong Kong enterprises with the
opportunity to attract the Mainland elite. By the end of February
this year, the Immigration Department had received about 2 400 applications
and had granted approval for over 1 950 qualified people from the
Mainland to work here. The task force that I head will ensure that
the application assessment procedures are conducted expeditiously
so as to enable Hong Kong to attract talented people more proactively.
Upgrading our human resources can help attract investment to Hong
Kong and create further employment opportunities.
Promoting Financial Co-operation between Hong Kong
and the Mainland, Reinforcing Our Status as an International Financial
Centre
25. Hong Kong is an international financial centre
and also a platform for the Mainland with the rest of the world.
We are committed to reinforcing this status and further enhancing
our role as the premier capital formation centre for China. The
biggest advantage of our financial market lies in its quality. On
listing in Hong Kong, enterprises from the Mainland and elsewhere
not only secure the capital they need but also achieve recognition
as being up to international listing standards. As at the end of
February this year, there were more than 260 Mainland enterprises
listed in Hong Kong, with a total market capitalisation of nearly
$1,900 billion. The total amount of capital raised by these enterprises
in Hong Kong exceeds $790 billion.
26. To keep pace with market development, we will
continue to improve our regulatory framework. One of our major tasks
is to enhance our corporate governance to keep it in line with international
standards. We have, together with the Securities and Futures Commission
(SFC) and Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing Limited (HKEx), implemented
a number of measures towards this end. We will continue to implement
the other measures outlined in our Corporate Governance Action Plan
together with proposals for strengthening the supervision of auditors
and raising the quality of financial reporting.
27. The Government has completed its consultation
on enhancing the regulation of listing. From this, there is general
support for expanding the existing "dual filing" system
and giving statutory backing to major requirements for listing.
We are discussing the relevant details and implementation timetable
with SFC and HKEx. We will announce by the end of this month the
consultation conclusions and the road map for implementing the recommended
improvements. We expect to introduce the relevant legislative amendments
early next year.
28. The CPG has agreed to banks in Hong Kong conducting
RMB business. This represents not only a breakthrough in the development
of our banking industry, but also an important milestone for financial
co-operation between the Mainland and Hong Kong and our economic
development. At present, 35 banks in Hong Kong are providing RMB
deposit-taking, exchange and remittance services. Total RMB deposits
in Hong Kong exceed RMB 2 billion. The value of transactions by
Mainland visitors using RMB cards averages $2.6 million a day and
is on the rise. We will continue discussions with the Mainland authorities
with a view to expanding the scope of RMB business once it has established
a firm foundation here.
29. The Chief Executive announced in this year's Policy
Address that the Government would strive to develop Hong Kong as
a world-class asset management centre. We are exploring, through
the Advisory Committee on Human Resources Development in the Financial
Services Sector, ways of encouraging the sector to work with tertiary
institutions to strengthen the training of local talent so as to
enhance the competitiveness of Hong Kong as an international asset
management centre. We will continue to improve our regulatory legislation
and systems so as to provide a more favourable market environment
for the launch of new investment products and the access of international
funds to the local market. We are also in discussion with the industry
on the detailed arrangements and the necessary legislative amendments
to exempt offshore funds from profits tax.
30. Although our banking system and securities market
are well established, we lack a mature bond market. Currently, the
total outstanding amount of bonds in Hong Kong is equivalent to
only about 45 per cent of our GDP, whereas in developed countries
such as the US and Japan, the rate is as high as 150 per cent. To
reinforce Hong Kong's position as an international financial centre,
we must redouble our efforts to develop the bond market, offering
diversified investment products and avenues for financing to attract
more overseas capital and enhance overall financial stability.
31. The Government has achieved much in this respect,
including provision of the necessary financial infrastructure, a
simplified issuance process and tax incentives. To promote the further
development of our bond market, we need to expand its size, product
range and liquidity. Apart from expanding the avenues for retail
issues, the Government will continue to encourage public corporations
to issue bonds and will itself issue different types of instruments
such as securitisation and government bonds. This will offer investors
more choice and promote the development of the local bond market.
Later, I will go into more detail concerning our plans to issue
government bonds.
Stimulating Tourism, Promoting Hospitality
32. After a very difficult period in the middle of
last year, the tourism sector recovered remarkably well. The number
of visitors to Hong Kong reached 15.5 million for the year. This
figure, although 6 per cent lower than that for 2002, is still the
second highest on record. Much of this recovery was attributable
to the continued growth of the Mainland market and the launch of
the Individual Visit Scheme. This scheme now covers Beijing, Shanghai
and most cities in Guangdong, and will be extended to cover the
whole of Guangdong by May this year. This will result in some 100
million Mainlanders becoming eligible to visit Hong Kong under the
scheme. The Government will continue its discussions with the Mainland
authorities with the aim of expanding the scheme to cover more provinces
and cities. The Hong Kong Tourism Board (HKTB) will step up its
promotional efforts to boost Hong Kong's image as Asia's premier
tourism destination.
33. A boom in the tourism industry will make the streets
of our city more lively. This will improve overall market sentiment,
stimulate local consumption, boost growth in related sectors and
contribute to the creation of employment opportunities, particularly
those for the lower-skilled workforce. I intend to provide additional
funding of about $95 million for various tourism promotion and training
activities.
34. The development of the tourism industry depends
on a concerted effort from the community. We must preserve the glamour
of Hong Kong as a cosmopolitan city and its reputation as a shopping
paradise by ensuring that our products are good value for money
and can attract people from around the world to come and make their
purchases here. We will continue to protect intellectual property
rights by cracking down on counterfeit goods. We will also continue
to promote a hospitable culture among those working in the tourism
sector in particular, and all our citizens in general. Specific
initiatives in this respect include a service quality audit in the
hotel, travel and transport industries; the expansion of the HKTB's
Quality Tourism Services Scheme; and seminars and campaigns to promote
awareness of the importance of a hospitable culture.
35. The Tourism Orientation Programme launched by
the HKTB has been very successful in introducing graduates to a
career in the tourism industry. Over the past two years, this programme
has groomed nearly 300 individuals for a career in the industry.
We will extend the programme for two more years in a bid to nurture
more talent in future for tourism.
36. We will carry out a series of studies to formulate
a strategy for future tourism development. The studies will cover
the potential for developing projects such as spa resort facilities.
We will also take forward the priority infrastructure projects on
Tung Ping Chau and in Tolo Harbour.
37. In addition, we will continue to encourage the
community to organise activities featuring individual district attractions.
Such activities can promote the local community economy and also
attract local and foreign visitors.
Fostering Creativity and Innovation, Moving Towards
High Value-added Industries
38. As Hong Kong gradually transforms into a knowledge-based
economy, our industries need to embrace new concepts, break with
tradition and move towards higher value-added outputs. The Government
will proactively encourage research and development, innovation
and design to help our industries move up the value chain. We will
focus on helping them switch the production mode from Original Equipment
Manufacturing to Original Design Manufacturing and thence Original
Brand Manufacturing. To enhance its competitiveness, we provide
support to the industrial sector through, for example, the provision
of competitively-priced land and comprehensive standards and accreditation
services. In addition, we are actively promoting Hong Kong brand
names to overseas and Mainland businesses and providing loan and
support schemes tailor-made for small and medium enterprises.
39. Whether it is in films, from "Buddha's Palm"
to "A Better Tomorrow" to "Infernal Affairs";
in graphic fiction, from "Master Q" to "My Boy"
to "McMug"; or in trend-setting jewelry, watches, fashion
and other innovative product designs, the creative industries of
Hong Kong have won worldwide recognition and achieved many outstanding
successes. Our performing arts sector has gained a foothold in Hollywood.
Moreover, CEPA has opened up the vast Mainland market to our film
industry. We will continue to promote creative industries and uphold
our robust protection of intellectual property rights, providing
an environment for creative, innovative and high value-added industries
to flourish.
40. Design is the soul of a product. A good design
can thoroughly remould our business, and significantly augment the
competitiveness of our products and services. To encourage more
product design activities in Hong Kong and further promote Hong
Kong brand names, we need to strengthen our support for design and
innovation. We plan to launch a "DesignSmart" initiative
with the creation of a $250 million fund. Apart from nurturing start-up
design ventures and training manpower in design and branding, it
will promote and honour design excellence. The initiative also includes
setting up a Design and Innovation Centre in order to attract design
talent from different places. Through these efforts, we seek to
instil into our industries high value-added, high intellectual property
and creativity content. We also wish to turn Hong Kong into a focal
point of design excellence in the region.
41. We will seek funding support from the Finance
Committee of this Council later. In addition, to facilitate this
promotional initiative, we will extend the profits tax deduction
for research and development expenses to cover expenses on design-related
activities. The relevant legislation will be introduced into this
Council as soon as practicable.
Co-ordinating Economic and Infrastructural Projects,
Facilitating Logistics Development
42. The development of Lantau is vital for our future.
In the next decade, we expect to focus on the development of economic
and infrastructural projects there. The Chief Executive announced
in his Policy Address in January that a Lantau Economic and Infrastructural
Development Co-ordination Task Force would be established to draw
up, from a "macro" perspective, a master blueprint for
the future development of Lantau. The Task Force will co-ordinate
the economic and infrastructural development of Lantau, following
the principle of sustainable development and balancing environmental,
social and economic considerations. This will ensure that the various
projects can be expedited and completed on schedule. In mid-February,
I convened the first meeting of the Task Force, at which several
development projects were tentatively identified.
43. The logistics industry, one of the major industries
of Hong Kong, provides many employment opportunities. We must reinforce
our position as Asia's premier international logistics hub. The
Task Force has decided to develop a Value-Added Logistics Park on
Lantau as soon as practicable, to provide one-stop integrated logistics
services and induce more high value-added cargo to pass through
Hong Kong. For the long-term development of the logistics industry,
we will expand our cross-boundary transport network and other infrastructural
facilities in order to maintain our competitive advantage amid rapid
logistics and port development in neighbouring areas.
44. In terms of international air cargo throughput,
Hong Kong leads the world. The Airport Authority is actively discussing
specific co-operation proposals with individual airports in the
PRD, including Shenzhen and Zhuhai. These proposals aim to attract
more passengers and cargo from the PRD to use Hong Kong International
Airport as a gateway, thereby strengthening our status as an international
and regional aviation centre.
Economic Performance and Prospects
Economic Performance in 2003
45. Our economic growth in the second quarter was
abruptly derailed by the impact of SARS. Yet, in the third quarter,
GDP staged a V-shaped rebound and recorded remarkable growth. For
2003 as a whole, GDP grew 3.3 per cent in real terms, a visible
improvement over the 2.3 per cent for 2002.
46. Our external trade in 2003 remained robust: total
exports of goods and offshore trade surged by 14.2 per cent and
16.5 per cent respectively in real terms. The tourism industry recovered
remarkably well after SARS. Local consumer spending revived progressively
throughout the second half of 2003, while investment spending also
reversed its downtrend towards the end of the year. Trading activity
in the property market picked up steadily. The number of homeowners
in negative equity has dropped from its peak of about 106 000 to
around 60 000 at present.
47. The employment situation continued to improve.
The unemployment rate fell successively from a peak of 8.7 per cent
in the middle of last year to 7.3 per cent early this year, with
the total number of unemployed persons decreasing by 64 200. While
the unemployment situation is still fraught with challenges, there
has been a distinct rise in employment and vacancies in many sectors.
Deflation is also tapering off. The year-on-year decline in the
Composite Consumer Price Index (CCPI) narrowed further from 1.9
per cent in December last year to 1.5 per cent in January this year,
and for 2003 as a whole the CCPI fell by an average of 2.6 per cent.
Economic Prospects for 2004
48. Looking ahead, external trade should maintain
solid growth in 2004. Recent indicators suggest that the external
economic environment continues to be generally sanguine. The US
economy has remained strong in recent months, and its near-term
outlook continues to be promising. The European Union economy should
be able to maintain steady if not faster growth this year. The recent
outbreak of avian influenza in a number of places in East Asia has
undoubtedly cast a shadow over the regional economic situation.
But with the support of a generally upbeat outlook for exports,
avian influenza is not expected to pose a serious threat to the
regional economy. Moreover, the general weakness of the US dollar,
coupled with the earlier substantial fall in Hong Kong's local costs
and prices, has boosted our external competitiveness. This should
bode well for our export performance. As to exports of services,
inbound tourism looks set for another surge this year, with the
further extension of the Individual Visit Scheme for Mainland visitors
and a progressive rebound in visitor arrivals from other places.
Separately, offshore trade and professional services are expected
to stay robust.
49. As regards domestic demand, there has been significant
improvement in both consumer and investor sentiment in the recent
period. A high level of bank liquidity, low interest rates, the
improved employment situation and a rebound in asset prices all
act to lift demand. Thus domestic demand this year can be expected
to be higher than last year.
50. In overall terms, the revival of the Hong Kong
economy in 2004 is expected to be more deeply seated and broadly
based. GDP is forecast to grow by 6 per cent in real terms. Deflation
should ease further and, for the year as a whole, the fall in the
CCPI is forecast to taper off distinctly to 1 per cent. Along with
the upturn in the overall economy, job opportunities should continue
to increase.
51. So far, the impact of avian influenza on our economy
is confined to the raising, importation and sale of poultry. Its
impact on our overall economy is expected to be minimal. The Government
has in place a comprehensive plan to deal with any contingencies
arising from the disease.
Medium-term Prospects
52. We have laid down a solid foundation for further
improvement of the economy. Growth momentum is good, and our medium-term
economic prospects remain upbeat. Sustained rapid economic growth
in the Mainland and the continued opening-up of its market will
create abundant business opportunities for Hong Kong. The implementation
of CEPA will help our enterprises make further inroads into the
Mainland market. Economic links between Hong Kong and the rest of
Asia are also expected to strengthen further. These positive factors,
together with sustained growth in the global economy, are conducive
to the development of the Hong Kong economy over the next few years.
53. With a rather bullish economic outlook for 2004
and with steady growth envisaged for the four years following, the
trend GDP growth rate in real terms over the medium term is forecast
at 3.8 per cent. As deflation is expected to dissipate progressively,
the trend rate of increase in the GDP deflator is forecast at 0.7
per cent. Combining these two forecasts, the trend growth rate of
nominal GDP over the period is forecast at 4.5 per cent.
54. But we still have to be alert to certain caveats,
including developments in the US economy following this year's presidential
election, movements in US interest rates and the US dollar exchange
rate, the ongoing situation in the European Union economy, and geopolitical
risks. Changes in these factors will have implications for the global
economic climate, and in turn for the medium-term outlook of our
economy.
Public Finances
Prudent Management of Public Finances, Achieving Fiscal
Balance
55. Despite this cautiously optimistic economic outlook,
we still need to address the problem of the fiscal deficit. The
health of our public finances has a major bearing on the stability
of our monetary and financial systems, investor confidence and overall
economic development. I am committed to upholding the important
principles stipulated in the Basic Law to manage public finances
prudently: keep expenditure within the limits of revenues and strive
to achieve a fiscal balance. I am also committed to keeping a simple
and low tax regime and maintaining the stability and integrity of
the monetary system.
56. After taking into account the impact of the SARS
outbreak on the economy, I announced in this Council on 22 October
last year our new target for achieving fiscal balance. The Government
will control expenditure strictly and is determined to reduce its
operating expenditure to $200 billion by 2008-09. We will also strive
to restore fiscal balance in the Operating and Consolidated Accounts
by 2008-09. Moreover, in line with the principle of "big market,
small government", I have pledged to bring public expenditure
down to 20 per cent of GDP or below.
57. In preparing for my maiden Budget, I consulted
members of the public, Members of this Council and representatives
of various groups. A special Budget web-page was also set up to
assist the public to express your views. Most of the feedback was
pragmatic and constructive, and some also very innovative. I have
listened carefully to all the views given. I understand that there
is some public dissatisfaction with the Government and that some
people are still experiencing the pain brought about by economic
adjustment. In his Policy Address in January, the Chief Executive
said that, while we would continue with economic restructuring and
revival, we should allow the community to be given a respite. In
this Budget, I am not going to make any major tax changes, so as
to sustain the momentum of economic recovery. I will seek to strike
a proper balance between reducing the fiscal deficit and safeguarding
people's livelihood in a pragmatic and proactive manner.
2003-04 Outturn
58. For 2003-04, total government spending is estimated
to be $252.9 billion and revenue $203.9 billion. The fiscal deficit
will be $49 billion (or 4 per cent of GDP), lower than the $78 billion
that I envisaged in October 2003. This is mainly due to the higher-than-expected
investment income from the fiscal reserves and revenue from profits
tax and stamp duty, and to the lower-than-expected expenditure this
year as a result of departments' continued efforts to streamline
their structures and re-engineer procedures. By 31 March this year,
our fiscal reserves will have dropped to $266.4 billion, the equivalent
of 13 months of government expenditure.
Estimates of Operating Expenditure
59. Government expenditure comprises operating expenditure
and capital expenditure. Operating expenditure is incurred by the
Government to meet its daily operational requirements and to provide
services. As such, it has long-term implications for the fiscal
outlook. We must therefore strictly contain our operating expenditure.
While accumulated deflation in terms of the GDP deflator has reached
20 per cent over the past five years, government operating expenditure
has increased by 12 per cent. Given the serious deficit problem,
operating expenditure should not keep on increasing. Reversing this
trend is my priority.
60. To contain government operating expenditure so
as to achieve the target reductions to $200 billion by 2008-09,
I have laid down guidelines for 2004-05 and the ensuing years. The
reductions will be gradual and I will adopt a pragmatic and measured
approach to their implementation: they will not be uniform across
all policy bureaux. The guidelines are as follows -
Financial Year
Operating Expenditure
| |
|
($ billion) |
|
| 2004-05 |
|
212.2 |
|
| 2005-06 |
|
210.6 |
|
| 2006-07 |
|
207.1 |
|
| 2007-08 |
|
203.5 |
|
| 2008-09 |
|
200.0 |
|
61. In line with the target that I announced on 22
October last year, in order to reduce operating expenditure from
$218 billion in 2003-04 to $200 billion in 2008-09, the total for
2004-05 should be $214.4 billion. Despite additional financial commitments
as a result of implementing measures to prevent epidemics and extend
temporary jobs, however, and in order to demonstrate our commitment
to streamline our establishment and reduce expenditure, I am still
holding government operating expenditure for 2004-05 to the level
of $212.2 billion as pledged in last year's Budget, but which had
not taken into account such expenditure items.
62. Many citizens have suggested to me that the Government
should cut down on expenditure before raising revenue. I fully agree
that the Government should first put its own house in order by containing
expenditure stringently before considering tax increases.
63. In order to reduce expenditure, we have already
begun streamlining departmental structures. The establishment of
the civil service has been reduced from 198 000 in early 2000 to
172 000 at present, with a further reduction to about 166 500 by
the end of March next year. We aim to cut the establishment to about
160 000 by 2006-07. As regards civil service pay, the first phase
of the pay cut was implemented in January this year, and the second
phase will come into effect 12 months later. A stable civil service
is a key element of Hong Kong's long-term development. In implementing
the foregoing measures, we will strive to maintain civil service
morale.
64. In reducing expenditure, we will make every effort
to do more with less while ensuring that essential services are
not affected. Last year, the Chief Secretary for Administration
designated the Director of Administration and the Head of the Efficiency
Unit to co-ordinate an exercise to review how the Government should
use resources more efficiently and avoid wastage. Directors of Bureaux
have proposed a number of initiatives in such areas as reprioritisation
of service provision, structural reorganisation and streamlining
of procedures. These management initiatives will not only achieve
savings for the Government, but also put public resources to more
effective use. The Government will continue to implement various
cost-saving measures.
65. I am very pleased that the community generally
agrees that reducing expenditure is the right direction and has
demonstrated support for resolving the problem of fiscal deficits.
As Financial Secretary, I have the difficult task of allocating
scarce resources within the community. An increase in resources
for certain policy areas means a reduction for others. However,
in order to eliminate the instability that persistently large budget
deficits bring, each policy area needs to do its bit. I would like
to take this opportunity to thank my colleagues for their understanding
and assistance.
Community Contribution
66. I can appreciate the concerns of the community
over expenditure on education and social welfare. The Government
will not waver in its commitment to invest in education and provide
for the disadvantaged. However, at the same time, we need to ensure
that public resources are being used most efficiently and opportunities
are created for the private sector to make its contribution.
67. In the case of education, we have seen a very
positive response to the matching grant scheme introduced for the
tertiary institutions. On the social welfare front, I have been
impressed by the commendable efforts of the social services organisations
to promote corporate social responsibility and encourage the business
sector to participate in community affairs. Under the "Caring
Company" campaign launched by the Hong Kong Council of Social
Service, for example, business organisations have been demonstrating
their concern for society in a number of ways, to the benefit of
our community.
68. At last month's public consultation forum, I said
that confidence in our future, care and fairness would be my guiding
principles in preparing the Budget. At the same time as I strive
to foster economic growth, I remain very concerned about our society's
development. Despite the current tight fiscal position, the Government
will earmark an additional $200 million on a one-off basis to promote
the development of a tripartite social partnership comprising the
Government, the business community and the welfare sector, and to
encourage corporations to take part in helping the disadvantaged.
The Health, Welfare and Food Bureau will consult the social welfare
sector on how best to use these funds, whether, for example, to
use a matching grant or other modality to incentivise the sector
to seek and secure corporate participation. I hope that this will
prime the pump and encourage various sectors of the community to
take up a share of social responsibility and work together to create
a cohesive, harmonious and caring society.
Estimates of Capital Expenditure
69. Capital expenditure is incurred mainly to finance
investments in infrastructure and the like. We will continue to
provide quality infrastructure to enhance the attractiveness of
Hong Kong as a centre for international trade, transportation and
communications, and to meet our future development needs.
70. Capital expenditure for 2004-05 is estimated to
be $46.5 billion. Over the next five years, capital expenditure
will amount to $43 billion a year on average, of which around $29
billion will be allocated to works projects.
71. Last year, we proposed a trial scheme for the
private sector to finance, build and manage recreational and cultural
facilities under Public Private Partnerships (PPP). The Home Affairs
Bureau has identified two pilot projects for private sector participation.
One comprises the construction of an ice sports centre, a tenpin
bowling centre and a town park in Tseung Kwan O. The other project
is for a leisure and cultural centre in Kwun Tong. We have drawn
up development plans for these two projects, and will invite the
private sector to finance, build and operate the facilities after
consulting the District Councils concerned and obtaining the support
of the Town Planning Board. Moreover, in response to suggestions
from many Members, we have further expanded the scope of our pilot
PPP projects. We have recently completed a preliminary feasibility
study on the reprovisioning of the Sha Tin Water Treatment Works
through PPP at a cost of some $6 billion, and the results are encouraging.
We are now considering the way forward in the light of these.
Allocation of Expenditure
72. We estimate that total government expenditure
for 2004-05 will be $258.7 billion. Expenditure on Education, Social
Welfare, Health and Security will account for about 60 per cent
of the total, with 23 per cent for Education, 26.4 per cent for
Social Welfare and Health, and 10.5 per cent for Security. In the
future allocation of expenditure, consideration will continue to
be given to the community's priorities.
Revenue
Giving Our Community a Respite
73. Last year's Budget contained a number of specific
proposals to raise revenue and relieve the pressure on our fiscal
deficit. The understanding and support of the community together
with Members of this Council have enabled the successful implementation
of nearly all of these measures and I am most grateful for that.
With the exception of the second phase of adjustments in salaries
tax, property tax and profits tax for unincorporated businesses,
which will apply from the 2004/05 year of assessment, these measures
have already come into effect. Upon full implementation, they will
generate nearly $13 billion annually in additional revenue for the
Government.
74. In this year's Budget, I propose no further increases
in salaries tax, profits tax or any other taxes. This respite will
allow the Hong Kong community and our enterprises to regather their
energy. It will also create conditions favourable for a sustained
economic recovery. I understand that some members of the community
would like me to reduce taxes. However, owing to our tight fiscal
position at present, there is really no room for major tax reductions.
75. As for rates, I have decided to maintain the charge
at 5 per cent. Since rateable values fell by an average of 8 per
cent last year, the amount of rates payable for the vast majority
of premises in the coming year will be lower. Not counting the effect
of the rates concessions for the third quarter of last year, we
expect that over 90 per cent of ratepayers will see an average reduction
of 11 per cent in their rates bill next year.
Extending the Salaries Tax Deduction for Home Loan
Interest
76. In the 1998/99 year of assessment, in order to
provide relief to households heavily burdened with home mortgage
payments, the Government introduced a salaries tax deduction, which
may be claimed for a total of five tax years, in respect of their
interest expenses.
77. In the course of preparing this Budget, I have
received suggestions from many people that the five-year limit for
this tax deduction should be extended. Mortgage rates have been
at a low level in recent years and there has been a 40 per cent
fall in property prices since the deduction became available. These
factors have helped substantially to reduce the burden of mortgage
interest payments on home buyers. The average amount of deduction
claimed has been decreasing and for 2002/03 stood at $30,000. The
burden of home mortgage repayments on taxpayers in general is lighter
now than at the time when the tax deduction was introduced. Nevertheless,
after taking into account the rather heavy financial load still
borne by many families, I propose to extend the limit for the deduction
by a further two years, that is, from five years to seven years,
with the maximum deduction in any year maintained at $100,000. This
concession will take effect from the 2003/04 year of assessment,
and will cost the Government $4.6 billion in tax revenue forgone
over five years. I envisage that several hundred thousand taxpayers
will benefit from this measure.
Extending the Duty Concession for Ultra Low Sulphur
Diesel
78. The duty on ultra low sulphur diesel is a steady
source of revenue. Several years ago, the Government introduced
the concessionary rate of $1.11 per litre for ultra low sulphur
diesel to encourage the transport industry to switch to cleaner
fuel. We have subsequently extended the concession on several occasions,
having regard to the impact of a weakening economy on the industry.
The concession is to expire at the end of this month and the duty
rate is due to revert to $2.89 per litre thereafter.
79. Although the economy has started to recover, the
transport industry and other related sectors still face many difficulties.
I have therefore decided to extend the concession for ultra low
sulphur diesel to the end of this year. Until then, the duty rate
will remain at $1.11 per litre. This proposal will cost the Government
nearly $0.9 billion in 2004-05.
Revenue-raising Measures, The "User Pays"
Principle
Personalised Vehicle Registration Marks Scheme
80. To raise revenue for the Government, I propose
to introduce a Personalised Vehicle Registration Marks Scheme in
addition to the existing arrangements for allocating and auctioning
vehicle registration marks. The proposed scheme will not affect
people's livelihood or business activities but will offer more choice
to vehicle owners. Under the scheme, a vehicle owner can choose
his preferred vehicle registration mark and use it upon approval
of his application by the Transport Department (TD) and following
a bidding exercise. To allow for more choice and add to the attraction
of the scheme, TD will substantially relax the restrictions on vehicle
registration marks for participating vehicle owners, to allow for
any combination of up to eight letters and numerals.
81. TD is actively making preparations for the scheme
with a view to inviting applications by the end of this year. In
a full year, the scheme is expected to generate additional revenue
of about $70 million for the Government. The Commissioner for Transport
will shortly provide further details.
82. The Government will, as soon as possible, introduce
legislation into this Council in respect of the home loan interest
deduction, the duty concession for ultra low sulphur diesel and
the Personalised Vehicle Registration Marks Scheme.
Government Fees and Charges
83. Government fees and charges are also a steady
source of revenue. The underlying principle for fees and charges
is "User Pays".
84. The Government has frozen most fees and charges
since 1998 as an exceptional measure to alleviate the financial
burden on the public in times of economic difficulty. In 2000-01,
when the economy was gradually picking up, the Government proposed
to adjust some fees and charges which did not affect people's livelihood.
However, only about 60 per cent of the fee increase proposals were
eventually approved by this Council.
85. While many people agree with the "User Pays"
principle, strong objections have arisen when the Government has
put forward specific proposals for fee revisions based thereon.
As a result, taxpayers have increasingly had to subsidise individual
users. Taking as examples visa fees and collection and disposal
charges for oily waste discharged by merchant ships, taxpayers are
subsidising 77 per cent and 56 per cent respectively of the cost.
This is unfair to them. We should not condone the practice of saying
one thing and doing another. We are duty-bound to reduce the amount
of subsidies given for various fees and charges, especially those
items not related to livelihood, in line with the "User Pays"
principle.
86. The Government will continue to exercise vigorous
cost control to reduce the pressure for fee increases. We will seek
Members' views on the revision of fees for government services.
We will first deal with fees that do not directly affect people's
livelihood or general business activities, such as the two examples
mentioned above. As government departments endeavour to cut costs,
there is room for downward adjustment of some government fees and
charges as well, and we will propose to reduce them accordingly.
I hope that Members will give our proposals for fee revisions a
fair and objective hearing.
"Green" Tax
87. In the course of the Budget consultations, quite
a number of people suggested to me that we should impose a "green"
tax on some polluting industries or products to promote environmental
protection and raise revenue. I agree that we should, through education,
enhance public awareness of environmental protection. But I believe
that the adoption of fiscal measures may also effectively change
people's polluting behaviour, thereby achieving our objective of
improving the environment.
88. As a matter of fact, for environmental reasons,
the Government imposes differential rates on some fuels, with a
view to encouraging vehicle owners to switch to environmentally
cleaner fuels so as to improve air quality. For example, in order
to encourage diesel taxis and light buses to switch from diesel
to LPG, we did not levy a duty on the latter. Recently, the Environment,
Transport and Works Bureau (ETWB) has proposed to levy a charge
for construction waste disposal. The purpose of this is to charge
fees on the basis of the "Polluter Pays" principle to
encourage the reduction of construction waste and waste sorting.
The ETWB is actively exploring ways to reduce the number of used
tyres dumped in landfills and to encourage tyre recycling. The Environmental
Protection Department (EPD) has engaged the industry in examining
various options. One of the options is to levy a tyre tax. EPD will
put forward specific proposals within this year for formal consultation.
89. I have also asked the Secretary for the Environment,
Transport and Works to review those tax and fee concessions which
run counter to the "Polluter Pays" principle, and consider
if they should be adjusted.
Other Taxes
Estate Duty
90. Many people have suggested to me that estate duty
be reviewed in order to attract foreign capital, thus developing
Hong Kong into the premier asset management centre for Asia. Towards
this end, we will study the effects on the economy and on government
revenue of adjusting estate duty and how best this should be effected
to achieve the purpose of attracting foreign capital. I will present
the findings of the study in next year's Budget.
Duty on Alcoholic Beverages
91. Many people have also suggested that reducing
the duty on alcoholic beverages can stimulate our tourism and retail
businesses, give rise to employment opportunities and enhance Hong
Kong's status as an international cosmopolitan city. In view of
the current financial situation, I consider that there is no scope
for adjusting the duty this year. However, we will continue to keep
this under review.
Capital Revenue
Sale of Government Assets and Securitisation
92. The Government announced in last year's Budget
that it would sell or securitise $112 billion in assets over the
next five years. Initially, we planned to realise $21 billion in
2003-04 from the sale of assets or through securitisation of revenues.
So far, we have sold a total of $15.5 billion worth of housing loans
to the Hong Kong Mortgage Corporation. This Council has recently
approved the securitisation of revenues from the government toll
tunnels and bridges. We expect to realise up to $6 billion from
this transaction in the next few months.
93. The Government is now consulting concerned parties
on the overall arrangements for the privatisation of the Airport
Authority. We hope that an initial consensus will be reached as
soon as possible so that the legislative process can commence. We
will shortly introduce into this Council an amendment bill to effect
capital restructuring of the Airport Authority in the meantime.
We have also set a tentative timetable for the rail merger. We plan
to conclude discussions with the two railway corporations within
six months. If the required legislative processes can be completed
next year, we hope to implement the airport privatisation and the
rail merger in 2005-06.
94. In accordance with the principle of "big
market, small government", we will continue to study the feasibility
of other corporatisation and privatisation proposals.
Issuance of Government Bonds
95. In order to enhance Hong Kong's competitiveness, it is incumbent
on the Government to continue investing in capital projects. To
provide greater flexibility in the management of our liquidity,
I propose issuing government bonds to fund infrastructure or other
investment projects which will bring long-term economic benefits
to Hong Kong. Another advantage of raising funds through issuing
bonds is the increased flexibility in the Government's asset sale
and securitisation programme, obviating the need to sell government
assets at low prices under unfavourable market conditions.
96. The issuance of government bonds will also help promote the
development of our bond market. At present, deposits in local banks
exceed $3,600 billion. The returns on these deposits are very low
because of the current low bank interest rates. Quality bonds are
an investment option that can provide a steady and higher return.
The issuance of government bonds could offer retail and institutional
investors such an option.
97. The present low interest-rate environment is favourable for
the issuance of government bonds. I propose that the Government
issue bonds not exceeding $20 billion in 2004-05. We will shortly
provide further details to this Council. We will decide whether
to issue additional bonds in future in the light of market conditions,
the amount of funds required for our investment projects and the
implementation of our asset sale and securitisation programme.
98. I must stress that the Government will not issue bonds for the
purpose of meeting operating expenditure. On the contrary, our principle
is that operating expenditure should be covered by operating revenue.
We will definitely not live on credit. We will continue to maintain
strict fiscal discipline and control of expenditure with a view
to restoring fiscal balance.
Medium Range Forecast and Fiscal Reserves
Medium Range Forecast
99. If our estimated economic growth is achieved and the proposals
are implemented in respect of expenditure and revenue and for issuing
government bonds, the medium range forecast for 2004-05 to 2008-09
will be as follows:
| Year |
2004-05 |
2005-06 |
2006-07 |
2007-08 |
2008-09 |
| |
($ billion) |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| Operating revenue |
165.6 |
170.7 |
177.7 |
184.9 |
194.8 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| Operating expenditure |
212.2 |
210.6 |
207.1 |
203.5 |
200.0 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
Operating surplus/(deficit) |
(46.6) |
(39.9) |
(29.4) |
(18.6) |
(5.2) |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| Capital revenue |
37.9 |
56.8 |
44.5 |
56.0 |
49.3 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
Capital spending (including payments
from the Capital
Investment Fund) |
53.4 |
52.3 |
45.9 |
39.6 |
37.1 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| Capital financing surplus/(deficit) |
(15.5) |
4.5 |
(1.4) |
16.4 |
12.2 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| Government bond issuance |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| - Proceeds |
20.0 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| - Interest expense |
0.5 |
1.0 |
1.0 |
1.0 |
1.0 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
Capital financing surplus/(deficit)
after bond issuance |
4.0 |
3.5 |
(2.4) |
15.4 |
11.2 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
Consolidated surplus/(deficit)
before bond
issuance |
(62.1) |
(35.4) |
(30.8) |
(2.2) |
7.0 |
| - as a percentage of GDP |
4.9% |
2.7% |
2.2% |
0.2% |
0.5% |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
Consolidated surplus/(deficit)
after bond
issuance |
(42.6) |
(36.4) |
(31.8) |
(3.2) |
6.0 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| - as a percentage of GDP |
3.4% |
2.7% |
2.3% |
0.2% |
0.4% |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| Fiscal reserves after bond issuance |
223.8 |
187.4 |
155.6 |
152.4 |
158.4 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
- as number of months of
Government
expenditure |
10 |
9 |
7 |
8 |
8 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| Public expenditure |
286.0 |
277.7 |
270.2 |
264.3 |
259.3 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| - as a percentage of GDP |
22.5% |
20.8% |
19.3% |
18.0% |
16.9% |
100. We forecast an operating deficit of $46.6 billion for 2004-05.
The operating deficit will gradually decline, falling to $5.2 billion
in 2008-09.
101. In respect of the consolidated account, we estimate that a
deficit of $42.6 billion will occur in 2004-05, equivalent to 3.4
per cent of GDP. The consolidated deficit will also gradually decline,
and a surplus of $6 billion will be recorded in 2008-09, equivalent
to 0.4 per cent of GDP.
102. While there will be a mild consolidated surplus in 2008-09,
the operating account for that year will still record a deficit.
To achieve the target of restoring fiscal balance by 2008-09, I
will review our economic and financial position annually and put
forward the necessary operating revenue proposals at the appropriate
time.
Fiscal Reserves
103. We expect that our fiscal reserves will be maintained over
the next five years in a range between $150 billion and $220 billion,
the equivalent of seven to 10 months of government expenditure.
104. During the Budget consultation, some people suggested that
we should transfer part of the investment income of the Exchange
Fund to the general revenue to ease the deficit problem. As Financial
Secretary, I agree that the Government should leave wealth with
the people. However, I must also take into account the need to maintain
the stability of our currency. In view of the extremely volatile
and unpredictable international monetary environment, we must maintain
abundant foreign reserves to preserve local and overseas confidence
in the Hong Kong dollar. Moreover, the investment return of the
Exchange Fund can fluctuate and is by no means a steady source of
income. Last year was a good example of this. We did not anticipate
that the Exchange Fund's return would be so high. In accordance
with the principle of prudent financial management, the Government
cannot rely excessively on such an unstable source of revenue. I
will review the situation from time to time so as to strike a proper
balance between leaving wealth with the people and maintaining a
stable currency.
Public Expenditure
105. Total public expenditure for 2004-05 is estimated to be $286
billion, or 22.5 per cent of GDP. The estimated figure for 2008-09
will be $259.3 billion, or 16.9 per cent of the GDP forecast for
that year, in line with the Government's target of containing public
expenditure at 20 per cent of GDP or below.
Broadening the Tax Base
Need to Secure Steady Revenues
106. Hong Kong's tax base is narrow. In the long run, we need to
broaden it to secure a steady source of revenue.
107. The following presents some data about Hong Kong's tax system
in comparison with member states of the Organisation for Economic
Co-operation and Development (OECD):
* In Hong Kong, non-tax revenue accounts for about 40 per cent of
total revenue, whereas the figure for OECD economies is around 14
per cent. This shows that Hong Kong has a far heavier reliance than
those economies on non-tax revenue, such as land revenue and investment
income.
* Our corporate profits tax accounts for 34 per cent of total tax
revenue, significantly higher than the 9 per cent for OECD economies.
* We have no taxes on general consumption. In OECD economies, revenue
from such taxes alone accounts, on average, for 18 per cent of the
local tax revenue. This excludes the revenue contributed by individual
taxes on specific goods and services.
108. Hong Kong is more reliant than the OECD economies on profits
tax and real property-related taxes or non-tax revenue. As revenue
from these sources is sensitive to economic fluctuations and our
types of taxes are limited, we are less able to tackle fiscal deficits
during economic downturns than other economies with more broadly-based
taxes. In most circumstances, we can only raise direct taxes, such
as profits tax and salaries tax, to increase our revenue significantly.
This may not be the best course of action in an economic downturn.
Furthermore, other places, in seeking to attract investment from
international enterprises in a globalised economy, are inclined
to lower their direct taxes progressively and make up for the reduction
in revenue by increasing consumption taxes. If we adopt the diametrically-opposed
policy of financing our deficit by increasing direct taxes, our
competitiveness will definitely be undermined.
Goods and Services Tax
109. In recent years, economies in all parts of the world have successively
introduced a goods and services tax (GST), sometimes known as a
value-added tax, to broaden their tax base and increase tax revenue.
Up to now, more than 120 countries have introduced this type of
tax. Hong Kong is the only developed economy that does not have
one. GST is broad-based and equitable, and is capable of yielding
a sizeable and steady revenue. According to a rough estimate, each
single percentage point in the rate of GST will yield revenue of
about $6 billion a year, assuming that no exemption is granted.
Depending on any exemptions, a GST of 5 per cent would generate
around $20-30 billion revenue for the Government in a full year.
Besides, being less sensitive than direct taxes to the cyclical
movement of the economy, GST can enhance the Government's ability
to withstand the pressure on public finances brought about by an
economic downturn. During the Budget consultation, quite a number
of professional bodies, business chambers and academics indicated
that they would support the introduction of GST, set at a low level,
in order to provide a steady source of income.
110. I appreciate the community's concerns that the introduction
of GST might add to the burden of low-income families. In our study
on whether to introduce GST, we will definitely take into full account
the possible impact on low-income families. From the experience
of other places in implementing GST, we have found that the actual
impact of the tax on low-income families will lessen if subsidies
are granted to them in parallel with the introduction of the tax.
Furthermore, the sizeable and steady revenue generated by the tax
would improve the Government's financial health. There might even
be some scope for reducing other taxes, such as salaries tax and
stamp duty.
111. Some people have indicated that the introduction of GST might
affect the tourism industry. We may draw on the experience of other
places, and consider introducing a tax refund scheme for visitors.
Under such a scheme, visitors would be allowed to apply for a refund
of GST paid for purchases in Hong Kong, thus minimising the possible
impact of GST on tourism.
112. As regards the impact of GST on the economy, experience shows
that in places that have introduced this tax in recent years, its
effects on prices are limited and short-term. Over the longer term,
these effects will generally disappear. A substantial increase in
profits tax and salaries tax simply for the sake of financing the
deficit could lead to a drain on capital and talent instead, thereby
undermining our competitiveness.
113. The Government has set up an internal committee to conduct
a detailed and comprehensive study on the implementation of a GST
in Hong Kong. It will draw on the practical experience of other
places and come up with a proposed GST framework suitable for Hong
Kong and an implementation timetable as a basis for discussion.
The committee will submit a report to me at the end of this year
upon completion of the study. After that, I will announce what will
be done next. We are likely to need at least three years to implement
GST. I hope that various sectors of the community will hold a rational
debate on this important subject and seek to reach consensus.
Concluding Remarks
114. Madam President, when I took up my post as Financial
Secretary in August last year, I said, "I am determined and
I have every confidence that I will be able to work closely with
our community to overcome our economic difficulties and develop
a prosperous, harmonious and caring society." Thanks to the
concerted efforts of the whole community, we are now moving towards
these goals.
115. In little more than half a year, Hong Kong has
witnessed a dramatic change in the economic climate. Our economy
has bottomed out with a V-shaped rebound, and businesses have revived.
I am very optimistic about our economic prospects. My optimism is
based not only on the opportunities brought about by the rapid growth
of our nation, but also on Hong Kong's unique strengths as well
as the tenacity, ingenuity and enterprising spirit of our people.
Our younger generation is very good at picking up new ideas and
knowledge, and is not afraid to experiment or innovate: this provides
a fresh impetus to our economic restructuring. I have every confidence
that by grasping our opportunities, constantly renewing our strengths
and making full use of our advantages, we can work another economic
miracle.
116. The Government is very clear about the path that
our economy should take and the direction for development that we
should follow. In economic policy-making, we will be proactive,
committed and consistent. In line with the principle that "market
leads and government facilitates", we will continue to create
the optimal environment for all businesses to flourish.
117. This is my maiden Budget. My policy on public
finances is based on the premise of "allowing the community
to take a respite and build up its strength" as expounded by
the Chief Executive. With the objectives of promoting people-based
governance, prudent management of public finances and leaving wealth
with the people, I will do my best to strike a balance between reducing
the fiscal deficit and safeguarding people's livelihood, so as to
give ourselves a breathing space to restore our vigour.
118. Madam President, it is now springtime when flowers
are coming into bloom, and we can see the early dawn of our economic
recovery. Let us work hand in hand, shoulder to shoulder, to realise
a bright future for Hong Kong.
Ends/Wednesday, March 10, 2004
NNNN
(Cantonese
/ Putonghua
/ English
)
|